Question Time AU

Question Time

House of Representatives

Tuesday 11 February 2025 · 14 questions

Summarised by AI in reported speech, not a transcript. Read the official Hansard · OpenAustralia

At a glance

Main topics

Taxation and Housing Policy, Critical Minerals Industry, Medical Workforce, Future Made in Australia, Taxation, Resources and Manufacturing Industry, Medicare, Cost of Living, Medicare: Bulk-Billing, Housing

Topics (select to filter)

Questions and answers

Q1 Peter Dutton Liberal Dickson 2:17 pm

Taxation

Background

The Leader of the Opposition sought a commitment from the Prime Minister regarding property tax settings.

Question

The member asked whether the Prime Minister would exclude any alterations to negative gearing and capital gains tax treatment on property during his tenure.

Answer from Anthony Albanese

The Prime Minister stated that the government's housing policy is the $32 billion Homes for Australia Plan, rather than changes to negative gearing. He highlighted the build-to-rent scheme, the Housing Australia Future Fund, and the Help to Buy scheme as key initiatives. He criticized the opposition for lacking positive policy ideas, citing their proposals for nuclear energy and business tax cuts as insufficient.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH) · 1 point of order raised

Q2 Zaneta Mascarenhas ALP Swan 2:22 pm

Critical Minerals Industry

Background

A government member asked about the impact of critical minerals policies on the future of the industry.

Question

The member asked how the government's critical minerals policies would benefit Australia and what approaches would harm workers and the sector.

Answer from Madeleine King

The Minister noted that the production tax credits for critical minerals had passed the Senate, providing a 10 per cent tax incentive to boost processing facilities and jobs. She cited support from industry leaders, including the CEO of the Association of Mining and Exploration Companies. She identified the opposition's vote against the legislation as the approach that would leave workers and the sector worse off.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Medical Workforce

Background

The member cited business closures and asked about the state of general practice under the current government.

Question

The member asked how many GP clinics had closed since the election of the Albanese government, noting that 27,000 small businesses had collapsed.

Answer from Mark Butler

The Minister took the question on notice to provide precise figures. He stated that general practice was in a parlous state upon the government's arrival due to a six-year freeze on Medicare rebates under the previous administration. He highlighted that the government had delivered three significant increases to the Medicare rebate, the largest in over 30 years, to rebuild general practice.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH) · 1 point of order raised

Future Made in Australia

Background

A government member inquired about job creation through manufacturing initiatives.

Question

The member asked how the Future Made in Australia plan was creating secure jobs and whether any alternative approaches would harm the manufacturing sector.

Answer from Ed Husic

The Minister emphasized the strategic importance of rebuilding manufacturing capability and reducing reliance on concentrated supply chains. He cited the National Reconstruction Fund and a $2 billion investment plan for aluminium smelters as key measures. He stated that the opposition's consistent rejection of these initiatives, including production tax credits, represented the alternative approach that would leave the sector worse off.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q5 Kate Chaney Ind Curtin 2:33 pm

Taxation

Background

The member raised the issue of bracket creep and tax transparency.

Question

The member asked whether the Treasurer agreed that indexing tax brackets, as done by 17 other OECD countries, would prevent reliance on income tax increases and improve transparency.

Answer from Jim Chalmers

The Treasurer acknowledged various suggestions for income tax reform but emphasized the government's focus on delivering tax cuts to all taxpayers. He noted that while some OECD countries index brackets, others do not, and that the government's chosen method of returning bracket creep benefits workforce participation. He stated that tax reform priorities must be balanced with public investment needs.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q6 Meryl Swanson ALP Paterson 2:36 pm

Resources Industry, Manufacturing Industry

Background

A government member asked about support for key industries.

Question

The member asked how the government was supporting resources and manufacturing industries and whether alternative approaches would harm people.

Answer from Anthony Albanese

The Prime Minister highlighted the securing of jobs in the Hunter region and the passage of production tax credits. He noted that the aluminium industry employs over 20,000 people directly and supports 55,000 indirectly. He criticized the opposition for voting against the legislation and cited historical opposition positions that favored exporting raw materials over domestic processing.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH) · 1 point of order raised

Q7 Terry Young LNP Longman 2:41 pm

Medicare

Background

The member cited a drop in bulk-billing rates in his electorate from 93 per cent to 79 per cent.

Question

The member asked why constituents were facing a bulk-billing crisis under the current government, given the fall in rates since 2019.

Answer from Mark Butler

The Minister attributed the pressure on bulk-billing to a six-year freeze on Medicare rebates under the previous government. He stated that the government had tripled the bulk-billing incentive, which had stopped the freefall and increased bulk-billing in every state and territory. He noted that six million free doctor visits were delivered last year.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH) · 2 points of order raised

Q8 Jerome Laxale ALP Bennelong 2:49 pm

Cost of Living

Background

A government member asked about economic management and cost-of-living pressures.

Question

The member asked how responsible economic management was easing cost-of-living pressures and whether alternative approaches would leave people worse off.

Answer from Jim Chalmers

The Treasurer listed tax cuts, energy bill relief, cheaper childcare, medicines, rent assistance, free TAFE, and better wages as key measures. He noted that inflation was down and wages were up, citing lowered inflation forecasts from major banks. He argued that the opposition's lack of costed policies and proposals for cuts to services would leave Australians worse off.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q9 James Stevens Liberal Sturt 2:52 pm

Medicare: Bulk-Billing

Background

The member cited a drop in bulk-billing rates in his electorate from 79 per cent to 69 per cent.

Question

The member asked why constituents were enduring a bulk-billing crisis under the current government, given the decline in rates since 2019.

Answer from Mark Butler

The Minister blamed the previous government for attempting to abolish bulk-billing and freezing Medicare rebates for six years. He stated that the government had tripled the bulk-billing incentive, which had stopped the slide in every state and territory, including South Australia. He emphasized that the government was strengthening Medicare after inheriting a difficult situation.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q10 Alison Byrnes ALP Cunningham 2:55 pm

Housing

Background

A government member asked about assistance for those facing housing stress.

Question

The member asked how the government was helping people with housing stress, what challenges existed, and whether alternative approaches would leave people worse off.

Answer from Clare O'Neil

The Minister highlighted the $32 billion investment in housing, including 55,000 social and affordable homes through the Housing Australia Future Fund. She noted that the first round would deliver 13,700 new homes. She criticized the opposition for blocking the Housing Australia Future Fund, build-to-rent schemes, and the Help to Buy program, stating these actions would leave people worse off.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q11 Angus Taylor Liberal Hume 2:59 pm

Superannuation

Background

The Shadow Treasurer questioned the taxation of unrealised capital gains in superannuation.

Question

The member asked why the Treasurer was persisting with taxing unrealised capital gains on superannuation assets, despite previous rulings against changes.

Answer from Jim Chalmers

The Treasurer explained that the policy makes modest changes to tax arrangements for super balances over $3 million, moving them from very concessional to concessional. He noted that the policy had been announced over two years ago and would raise a couple of billion dollars annually to fund Medicare. He argued that the opposition would instead cut Medicare, housing, or pensions to find savings.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q12 Josh Burns ALP Macnamara 3:01 pm

Schools

Background

A government member asked about improvements to the school education system.

Question

The member asked what the government was doing to build a fairer school system and whether alternative approaches would leave Australians worse off.

Answer from Jason Clare

The Minister cited agreements with multiple states and territories for the biggest new investment in public education, including phonics and numeracy checks and free catch-up tutoring. He criticized the previous government for cutting $30 billion from school funding, which he linked to a drop in high school completion rates. He stated that the opposition would cut this funding if elected.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q13 Dai Le Ind Fowler 3:05 pm

Cost of Living

Background

The member raised concerns about rising energy costs and the adequacy of current rebates.

Question

The member asked what real reforms the government would introduce to fix the electricity market and lower energy prices, noting that councils were facing doubled costs.

Answer from Anthony Albanese

The Prime Minister highlighted that inflation had fallen to 2.4 per cent and real wages were increasing. He noted that constituents benefited from tax cuts, cheaper medicines, free TAFE, and urgent care clinics. He defended the $300 energy rebates as effective in reducing bills for households and small businesses.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH) · 1 point of order raised

Q14 Luke Gosling ALP Solomon 3:09 pm

Veterans

Background

A government member asked about progress on veteran compensation claims.

Question

The member asked what the government had done to clear the backlog of veteran compensation claims and whether threats to this progress existed.

Answer from Matt Keogh

The Minister stated that the government had engaged 500 additional staff to address a backlog of 42,000 claims, resulting in faster processing times. He identified the opposition's proposals to cut staff in the Department of Veterans' Affairs as a threat that would leave veterans worse off by reducing support services.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Other debates this day (20)

Albanese Government General Debate Andrews, Hon. Kevin James, AM; Reference to Federation Chamber Condolence · listed Appropriation Bill (No. 2) 2024-2025; Third Reading Bill Debate · listed Appropriation Bill (No. 3) 2024-2025, Appropriation Bill (No. 4) 2024-2025, Appropriation (Parliamentary Departments) Bill (No. 2) 2024-2025; Second Reading Bill Debate Appropriation Bill (No. 3) 2024-2025, Appropriation Bill (No. 4) 2024-2025, Appropriation Bill (No. 2) 2024-2025; Second Reading Bill Debate Appropriation Bill (No. 3) 2024-2025, Appropriation Bill (No. 4) 2024-2025, Appropriation Bill (No. 2) 2024-2025; Third Reading Bill Debate · listed Appropriation Bill (No. 4) 2024-2025; Third Reading Bill Debate · listed AusCheck Amendment (Global Entry Program) Bill 2025; Second Reading Bill Debate AusCheck Amendment (Global Entry Program) Bill 2025; Third Reading Bill Debate · listed Cost of Living Matter of Public Importance Customs Amendment (Expedited Seizure and Disposal of Engineered Stone) Bill 2024, Electricity Infrastructure Legislation Amendment Bill 2025; Reference to Federation Chamber Bill Debate · listed Education General Debate Electricity Infrastructure Legislation Amendment Bill 2025; Second Reading Bill Debate Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024; Consideration of Senate Message Bill Debate · listed Health Care, Schools General Debate Housing, Parramatta Electorate: Pongal General Debate Newcastle Electorate General Debate Social Security Legislation Amendment (Technical Changes) Bill 2025; Second Reading Bill Debate Social Security Legislation Amendment (Technical Changes) Bill 2025; Third Reading Bill Debate · listed Sunshine Coast: Infrastructure General Debate

Divisions on this day (2)

1. Rearrangement Not passed 57–81 2. Social Security Legislation Amendment (Technical Changes) Bill 2025; Second Reading Passed 81–5