Question Time AU

Question Time

Senate

Monday 10 February 2025 · 10 questions

Summarised by AI in reported speech, not a transcript. Read the official Hansard · OpenAustralia

At a glance

Main topics

Indigenous policy and infrastructure, Women's health funding, Income management in the Northern Territory, Closing the Gap progress, International education and qualifications, Mining industry and environmental laws, Truth-telling and Makarrata Commission, Queensland floods and emergency response, Public Service workforce levels, Workplace relations and wages

Topics (select to filter)

Questions and answers

First Nations Australians

Background

The member raised concerns that routine business in the Indigenous portfolio had stalled during the Voice referendum campaign, citing the non-replacement of the Community Development Program and paused grants.

Question

The member asked why practical outcomes for Indigenous Australians were not a priority, noting that the Productivity Commission highlighted a lack of data on clean drinking water access in Indigenous communities.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Malarndirri McCarthy

The minister stated that the government had replaced the Community Development Program with the Remote Jobs and Economic Development program, which was creating meaningful jobs in remote communities. She cited examples from Western Australia and the Northern Territory where participants were already benefiting. Regarding water security, she noted that Minister Plibersek had identified specific communities needing support and that proper water infrastructure was essential for deploying dialysis units. She confirmed that applications for the second round of the remote jobs program were open.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Women's Health

Background

The government announced an investment of over half a billion dollars to improve healthcare choices and reduce costs for women.

Question

The member asked what specific benefits the policy would deliver for women and how it would reduce their healthcare expenses.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Katy Gallagher

The minister explained that the funding, sourced from budget repairs, would list common contraceptive pills and menopause hormone therapies on the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme from 1 March. She stated these listings would save women up to $577 annually if they held a concession card. The investment also included expanding endometriosis and pelvic pain clinics, raising their count from 22 to 33, with existing clinics receiving increased funding for perimenopause and menopause care. Additionally, centres of excellence would be established to train general practitioners.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Pensions and Benefits

Background

The member questioned the government's commitment to ending mandatory income management, citing previous statements by Labor members supporting the scheme.

Question

The member asked if the government had realized the benefits of mandatory income management and whether it should have promised to remove it.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister stated that the government was implementing a long-term strategy to overhaul income management in partnership with First Nations people and other stakeholders. She noted that consultations with approximately 412,000 community members indicated a preference for a longer transition period to voluntary income management. She clarified that income management rules in the Northern Territory had not changed since 2007 and that the NT government could refer adults to income management for child protection concerns, quarantining 70 per cent of payments. She emphasized that decisions would be based on genuine consultation with communities.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH) · 3 points of order raised

Q5 Jana Stewart ALP VIC 2:23 pm

Closing the Gap

Background

The government released its annual Closing the Gap report and implementation plan.

Question

The member asked what steps the government was taking in partnership with First Nations communities and other governments to deliver real change.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Malarndirri McCarthy

The minister outlined the Remote Jobs and Economic Development program, which would create up to 3,000 jobs over three years, and the expansion of the Indigenous Rangers Program by 1,000 positions. She noted that over 200 new homes had been built in remote Northern Territory communities and that the Connected Beginnings program was expanding to 50 communities. She also highlighted increased funding for legal services and family violence prevention, and justice reinvestment initiatives in 27 sites. For 2025, she announced $842 million for essential services in the NT, ending freight costs on 30 household items in 76 remote stores, and upskilling 120 local staff.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q6 Malcolm Roberts One Nation QLD 2:29 pm

Education Standards

Background

The member raised concerns about the mutual recognition of qualifications between India and Australia and alleged issues with degree authenticity.

Question

The member asked if Indian degrees were given equal merit to Australian degrees and whether the government would verify the legitimacy of qualifications, particularly in health and engineering.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister stated she would seek further advice on mutual recognition schemes and noted that consumer safety remained paramount. She clarified that while mutual recognition agreements exist, specific professions often have separate registration requirements to ensure practitioners have the necessary qualifications. Regarding the balance of domestic and international students, she noted that the government had announced caps on international student numbers to maintain education quality. She emphasized that international education was an important export industry that contributed to the economy, but the government aimed to gradually lower international student enrolments.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Mining Industry

Background

Reports suggested the Prime Minister was engaging with the mining sector despite previous criticisms of the industry.

Question

The member asked if the Prime Minister would promise to permanently abandon nature positive laws and reverse the decision on the McPhillamys gold mine.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister confirmed that the nature positive legislation would not be reintroduced, stating that the government was committed to law reform to deliver faster project approvals and better environmental protection. Regarding the McPhillamys gold mine, she noted that the decision was made by the responsible minister under statutory powers and that the company had commenced legal proceedings in the Federal Court. She highlighted that the government had approved 40 mining projects and doubled the rate of on-time approvals. She challenged the member to support production tax credits for the mining sector if they were genuinely pro-mining.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q8 Dorinda Cox Greens WA 2:38 pm

Indigenous Australians: Truth-Telling

Background

The member questioned the government's commitment to truth-telling and treaties following the Voice referendum.

Question

The member asked why the government was abandoning its 2022 commitment to federal processes for truth-telling and treaties.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Malarndirri McCarthy

The minister stated that the government had not moved away from the principles of the Uluru Statement from the Heart. She explained that the government was waiting for the outcomes of the Senate inquiry into truth-telling, which included submissions from hundreds of people. She noted that the government had campaigned on various issues in 2022, including the referendum, but had prioritized cost-of-living measures upon taking office. She confirmed that the government would wait for the inquiry's recommendations before deciding on next steps.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q9 Nita Green ALP QLD 2:42 pm

Queensland: Floods

Background

Severe weather and flooding were impacting communities across North Queensland.

Question

The member asked for an update on the current situation and the support available to affected communities.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Jenny McAllister

The minister reported that the situation remained dynamic, with flood warnings in place across the region. She noted that the Australian Defence Force had assisted with recovery efforts, including constructing a temporary bridge on the Bruce Highway. The government had activated disaster recovery payments and personal hardship assistance for worst-impacted communities. Concessional loans were available to farmers, small enterprises, and charitable organisations. An $8 million community relief fund was established to support local councils. She also highlighted investments in the national aerial firefighting fleet and emergency stockpile.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q10 Jane Hume Liberal VIC 2:47 pm

Australian Public Service

Background

Parliamentary Budget Office analysis suggested the Public Service would decrease by more than 20,000 staff over four years.

Question

The member asked if the government had decided to keep the Public Service at current levels or if there was an $11.1 billion funding gap.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister criticized the opposition's credibility on public service issues, citing previous cuts under the Liberal government. She explained that the budget forecasts used the same methodologies as the former government, with entities forecasting their own wage and salary expenditures. She stated that the opposition's claim of a 'black hole' was misleading and contrasted it with the opposition's proposed nuclear power plan. She reiterated that the approach to APS wages was consistent with past practices and challenged the opposition to specify where their proposed cuts would come from.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH) · 1 point of order raised

Workplace Relations

Background

The member highlighted positive feedback from workers regarding workplace relations reforms.

Question

The member asked how government policies were helping Australians earn more and why secure, well-paid jobs were critical.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Murray Watt

The minister stated that workplace relations changes had led to real wages growing for four consecutive quarters and the creation of over one million jobs since May 2022. He noted that the gender pay gap had reached an unprecedented low, as female average weekly earnings rose by $173.80. He emphasized that the right to disconnect helped reduce unpaid overtime and that casual workers had a clearer pathway to permanency. He contrasted these outcomes with the opposition's plan to repeal these rights, arguing that workers would be worse off under a Liberal government.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Other debates this day (13)

Answers to Questions Take Note Debate Commonwealth Workplace Protection Orders Bill 2024, Health Legislation Amendment (Improved Medicare Integrity and Other Measures) Bill 2025; First Reading Bill Debate · listed Commonwealth Workplace Protection Orders Bill 2024, Health Legislation Amendment (Improved Medicare Integrity and Other Measures) Bill 2025; Second Reading Bill Debate Competition and Consumer Amendment (Australian Energy Regulator Separation) Bill 2024, Workplace Gender Equality Amendment (Setting Gender Equality Targets) Bill 2024; First Reading Bill Debate · listed Competition and Consumer Amendment (Australian Energy Regulator Separation) Bill 2024, Workplace Gender Equality Amendment (Setting Gender Equality Targets) Bill 2024; Second Reading Bill Debate Cost of Living Matter of Public Importance Defence Service Homes Amendment (Insurance) Bill 2025; Second Reading Bill Debate Defence Service Homes Amendment (Insurance) Bill 2025; Third Reading Bill Debate · listed Education Standards Take Note Debate Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024; In Committee Bill Debate Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024; Second Reading Bill Debate Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024; Third Reading Bill Debate · listed Women's Health Take Note Debate

Divisions on this day (18)

1. Rearrangement Not passed 28–35 2. Rearrangement Passed 34–27 3. Rearrangement Passed 34–27 4. Rearrangement Passed 34–27 5. Rearrangement Passed 34–27 6. Rearrangement Passed 34–27 7. Rearrangement Passed 33–27 8. Rearrangement Not passed 27–33 9. Community Affairs References Committee; Reference Not passed 21–36 10. Consideration of Legislation Not passed 31–31 11. Cost of Living Not passed 28–33 12. Environment and Communications References Committee; Reference Not passed 25–31 13. Environment and Communications References Committee; Reference Not passed 25–31 14. Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024; Second Reading Not passed 14–26 15. Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024; Second Reading Passed 33–27 16. Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024; In Committee Not passed 28–32 17. Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024; In Committee Passed 32–28 18. Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024; Third Reading Passed 34–28