Question Time AU

Question Time

Senate

Tuesday 4 February 2025 · 11 questions

Summarised by AI in reported speech, not a transcript. Read the official Hansard · OpenAustralia

At a glance

Main topics

Antisemitism and foreign policy, Queensland floods and disaster response, National security and antisemitism, Dental health and Medicare, Cost of living and inflation, Online safety and digital duty of care, Genetic testing and insurance discrimination, Ambassador appointment and Defence conduct, Economy and inflation, Energy policy and food costs

Topics (select to filter)

Questions and answers

Antisemitism

Background

The question followed statements by Israeli officials linking the rise in antisemitism in Australia to the government's stance on Israel, including an attack on a Melbourne synagogue.

Question

The member asked whether the government would acknowledge that its international actions against Israel were fueling the crisis of antisemitism in Australia.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister stated that Australia's position in the United Nations reflected international concern and aligned with countries such as Canada, the United Kingdom, New Zealand, Japan, and Korea. She argued that conflating government concerns about the humanitarian situation in Gaza with antisemitism was unhelpful, noting that the government advocated for a ceasefire and peace for both Israelis and Palestinians. She condemned the rise in antisemitism as unacceptable and rejected hate acts, including slogans outside the Sydney Opera House. In response to supplementary questions regarding specific attacks and UN motions, she reiterated that the government consistently condemned Hamas and called for hostage releases, dismissing the suggestion that it supported one-sided motions as misinformation. She noted that the opposition leader had opposed a ceasefire supported by US presidents.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q2 Tony Sheldon ALP NSW 2:08 pm

Queensland: Floods

Background

Severe weather and flooding affected communities across North Queensland, cutting off areas and causing loss of life.

Question

The member asked for an update on the current situation regarding the floods in North Queensland and how the government would support recovery efforts.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Murray Watt

The minister reported that widespread rainfall had caused flooding over an area spanning more than 400 kilometres, cutting off many communities. He noted that five national helicopters, including assets from the Australian Defence Force, were supporting state emergency services, marking the first deployment of national aerial assets outside of bushfires. He expressed condolences for the death in Ingham and thanked first responders. In response to supplementary questions, he confirmed that personal hardship payments of $180 for individuals and up to $900 for families of five or more had been activated for specific regions. He also announced a period of emergency for childcare services in North Queensland, providing gap-fee waivers. Regarding long-term preparation, he highlighted a disaster preparedness program involving over 2,500 people, an additional $35 million commitment for aerial capability, and nearly $750 million invested in the Disaster Ready Fund for projects such as cyclone shelters and drainage improvements.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Antisemitism

Background

A caravan containing explosives allegedly intended to target Sydney's Jewish community was discovered in Dural, New South Wales.

Question

The member asked when the Prime Minister was first briefed on the discovery of the explosive-laden caravan.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister declined to provide a specific date, stating that the government does not comment on operational matters regarding national security to avoid undermining police investigations. She emphasized that the priority was ensuring those responsible faced the full force of the law and that the community should show solidarity with the Jewish community. In response to supplementary questions, she reiterated that the government takes advice from national security agencies rather than political commentators and dismissed the opposition's focus on the timing of briefings as playing politics with a serious investigation.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q4 Larissa Waters Greens QLD 2:18 pm

Dental Health

Background

The Greens advocated for including adult dental care in Medicare, citing high costs and corporate tax avoidance.

Question

The member asked whether the government would tax big corporations to fund the inclusion of dental care in Medicare for all Australians.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Malarndirri McCarthy

The minister referred tax policy questions to the Minister for Health and Aged Care but highlighted the government's investment of $6.1 billion to strengthen Medicare, including two large rebate increases and the opening of 87 urgent care clinics. She noted that the government was developing a new national oral health plan with states and territories. In response to supplementary questions, she stated that the government was providing $215.6 million over two years to state and territory governments for public dental services for adults, as these services are a state responsibility. She also highlighted the Child Dental Benefits Schedule, which had delivered $3.1 billion in benefits to 3.5 million children, and support for private dental services through health insurance rebates.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH) · 2 points of order raised

Cost of Living

Background

The government sought to highlight its cost-of-living measures and contrast them with the opposition's policies.

Question

The member asked how the government was delivering cost-of-living relief without adding to inflation.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister listed government measures including tax cuts for all taxpayers, cheaper childcare and medicines, boosted bulk-billing, 75 free Medicare urgent care clinics, energy bill relief, fee-free TAFE, reduced HECS debts, and expanded paid parental leave. She noted that inflation had fallen from the six per cent range to the two per cent range. In response to supplementary questions, she emphasized ongoing efforts to crack down on unfair pricing and deliver better bargaining rights for workers, promising a further 20 per cent slash in student debts if re-elected. She contrasted this with the opposition's plan for $350 billion in secret cuts and $10 billion in tax breaks for business lunches, arguing that the opposition's policies would worsen the cost of living.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Cybersafety

Background

A review of online safety laws recommended a digital duty of care, but reports suggested no timeline for legislation.

Question

The member asked for the reasons behind the recommendation for a digital duty of care and whether the government was still committed to legislating it promptly.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Malarndirri McCarthy

The minister confirmed the government's commitment to keeping Australians safe online, noting that penalties for breaches had been increased from less than $1 million to $50 million. She stated that a digital duty of care would be legislated to place the onus on platforms, alongside other measures such as a minimum age for social media and laws against deepfakes. In response to supplementary questions about the lack of a timeline, she asserted that the government was not sitting idle and was working through recommendations to balance safety with free speech. She clarified that the government was not contemplating changes to allow the eSafety Commissioner to remove content overseas.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q7 David Van Ind VIC 2:36 pm

Insurance: Genetic Testing

Background

The Assistant Treasurer announced plans to ban the use of predictive genetic test results in life insurance underwriting.

Question

The member asked for an update on the progress of legislation to prevent discrimination based on genetic screening results.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Katy Gallagher

The minister confirmed that the Assistant Treasurer had announced plans to introduce legislation to prevent discrimination based on predictive genetic test results in life insurance. She stated that Treasury would soon consult on how to shape the proposed draft legislation. In response to supplementary questions, she indicated that a consultation process on an exposure draft was underway, suggesting it would be difficult to pass the legislation before the federal election due in May, as proper consultation requires time.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q8 Jacqui Lambie JLN TAS 2:40 pm

Campbell, General Angus, AO, DSC (Retd)

Background

Retired General Angus Campbell was appointed as Australia's ambassador to Belgium, Luxembourg, the EU, and NATO.

Question

The member asked for the terms of appointment, salary, and benefits for General Campbell, citing concerns about his record during his time as Chief of the Defence Force.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister stated that General Campbell was appointed due to his experience and skills, particularly relevant for engagement with NATO. She agreed to provide the specific terms, salary, and benefits details if possible before the end of question time, noting that the terms were standard for the post. In response to supplementary questions about resources and trade expertise, she indicated that no particular changes to the Brussels post were anticipated and that trade negotiations are led by DFAT trade negotiators rather than ambassadors. She also noted that appropriate processes had been undertaken regarding allegations related to the Brereton report.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Economy

Background

The government sought to highlight its economic management and contrast it with the opposition's policies.

Question

The member asked for an update on the government's work to fight inflation and strengthen the economy.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Katy Gallagher

The minister stated that the government had reduced inflation to almost a third of its previous level, grown jobs by 1.1 million, and delivered budget surpluses. She noted that the government had lowered the inherited debt by $177 billion and reduced interest payments by $70 billion. In response to supplementary questions, she highlighted that wages were growing and unemployment remained low. She contrasted this with the opposition's plan for $350 billion in cuts to fund $600 billion in nuclear reactors and tax breaks for business lunches, arguing that the opposition's policies would worsen the economic situation.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q10 Bridget McKenzie Nationals VIC 2:51 pm

Energy

Background

Food distributors claimed that government energy policies were increasing food prices.

Question

The member asked why the government's energy policies were increasing the cost of food for Australians, citing statements from industry representatives.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister argued that the opposition's alternative policy of investing $600 billion in nuclear power would result in more expensive energy and higher costs for consumers. She stated that renewable energy is the cheapest form of new energy and that the current high prices were a consequence of the previous government's failure to invest and provide certainty. In response to supplementary questions about specific companies' cost increases, she reiterated that the opposition had voted against $3 billion in energy bill relief for millions of Australians and that their policies would lead to higher household bills.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH) · 2 points of order raised

Wages

Background

An independent interim review of the Secure Jobs, Better Pay legislation was released, finding positive outcomes.

Question

The member asked what the independent review revealed about wages and why secure jobs and better pay are critical for cost-of-living relief.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Murray Watt

The minister reported that the interim review found a significant rise in employees under collective agreements and that wages were starting to improve. He noted that full-time workers were earning an extra $213 a week in median terms compared with three years ago, real wages had risen for four consecutive quarters, and the gender pay gap was at a historic low. In response to supplementary questions, he emphasized that the opposition had voted against these workplace laws and promised to repeal protections such as the right to disconnect and same job, same pay laws, arguing that this would worsen the economic situation for workers.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Other debates this day (8)

Administrative Review Tribunal (Miscellaneous Measures) Bill 2024; Second Reading Bill Debate Antisemitism Take Note Debate Antisemitism General Debate Dental Health Take Note Debate Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024, Health Insurance (Pathology) (Fees) (Repeal) Bill 2024, Health Legislation Amendment (Modernising My Health Record--Sharing by Default) Bill 2024, Navigation Amendment Bill 2024; Second Reading Bill Debate Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024, Health Insurance (Pathology) (Fees) (Repeal) Bill 2024, Health Legislation Amendment (Modernising My Health Record--Sharing by Default) Bill 2024, Navigation Amendment Bill 2024; First Reading Bill Debate · listed Nature Positive (Environment Protection Australia) Bill 2024, Nature Positive (Environment Information Australia) Bill 2024, Nature Positive (Environment Law Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2024 Matter of Public Importance United States of America Matter of Public Importance

Divisions on this day (5)

1. Antisemitism Not passed 25–35 2. Department of Employment and Workplace Relations; Order for the Production of Documents Not passed 18–23 3. Department of Education; Order for the Production of Documents Not passed 29–33 4. Nature Positive (Environment Protection Australia) Bill 2024, Nature Positive (Environment Information Australia) Bill 2024, Nature Positive (Environment Law Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2024 Not passed 27–31 5. United States of America Not passed 12–25