Question Time AU

Question Time

Senate

Thursday 13 February 2025 · 9 questions

Summarised by AI in reported speech, not a transcript. Read the official Hansard · OpenAustralia

At a glance

Main topics

Health Care Regulation and Antisemitism, Cost of Living: Energy and Mortgages, Tasmania Bushfires and Environmental Protection, Women's Health Package, HELP Debt Indexation, Creative Australia and Venice Biennale, Climate Change Targets, Trade with the United States, Cost of Living: Mortgages and Food

Topics (select to filter)

Questions and answers

Health Care

Background

Nurses at Bankstown Hospital in New South Wales made antisemitic threats, leading to their immediate suspension by the state health minister. Concerns were raised that these individuals could still practice in other jurisdictions.

Question

The senator asked what steps the Prime Minister had taken to prevent the suspended nurses from practicing as health professionals in any state or territory, given that NSW Health had stood them down but national registration remained possible.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister expressed shock at the incident and noted universal condemnation of the antisemitism. She explained that adverse findings by NSW Health automatically flow through to the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency, the national regulator. Regarding the supplementary questions, she stated that the AFP would assist NSW Police in their investigation and referenced Special Operation Avalite. She declined to commit to a National Cabinet meeting, instead inviting the opposition to stand united against antisemitism.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH) · 1 point of order raised

Cost of Living

Background

The Prime Minister had previously promised to reduce power bills by $275 and provide cheaper mortgages. The question challenged whether these promises had been delivered.

Question

The senator asked if the Prime Minister had delivered on pre-election promises to reduce power bills by $275 and provide cheaper mortgages, citing the ongoing cost-of-living crisis.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister stated that energy relief had cut $300 off power bills and $650 for small businesses, contrasting this with the opposition's nuclear policy which she claimed would raise prices by $1,200. Regarding mortgages, she pointed to falling inflation, rising wages, and falling unemployment. She highlighted the Help to Buy shared equity scheme as assistance for homeowners. She refused to admit to mistakes, instead accusing the opposition of past failures regarding hospital funding and Medicare.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH) · 5 points of order raised

Q4 Nick McKim Greens TAS 2:21 pm

Tasmania: Bushfires

Background

Fires in the Takayna/Tarkine wilderness had burned for 10 days, destroying a grove containing the world's oldest known Huon pine. Other ancient ecosystems were threatened.

Question

The senator asked why more effort was not made to extinguish the fires early and what the government was doing to protect these globally significant ecosystems.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Jenny McAllister

The minister noted that firefighting is a state responsibility but highlighted federal support, including the deployment of the national large air tanker and a heavy-lift helicopter. She emphasized that this was the first high-risk season with these assets available due to government investment in the national aerial fleet and the National Emergency Management Agency. She disputed the claim that recommendations from a 2016 Greens inquiry were ignored, citing the $1 billion Disaster Ready Fund and investments in early detection technologies.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Women's Health

Background

The government announced a $570 million package responding to Senate inquiries on reproductive and menopause health. The question sought to outline the benefits of this package.

Question

The senator asked how the women's healthcare package responded to Senate inquiries and delivered for Australian women, particularly regarding economic security and workforce participation.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Katy Gallagher

The minister detailed the $573 million package, which included the first PBS listing for new oral contraceptives in 30 years, new menopausal hormone therapies, and more endometriosis clinics. She noted that these measures would save women thousands of dollars. Regarding economic security, she cited data showing women retire earlier due to health issues, costing the economy $72 billion annually in lost GDP. She argued the package improves affordability and access, thereby supporting workforce participation.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Universities

Background

The government announced changes to HELP debts to assist with home loans. The question challenged the timing of indexation, arguing it penalizes graduates by charging interest before yearly payments are counted.

Question

The senator asked why the government had not changed the timing of HELP debt indexation to save graduates money immediately, instead prioritizing changes that did not provide immediate savings.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Murray Watt

The minister explained that the indexation rate was adjusted in the budget to address high inflation inherited from the previous government. He noted that inflation has since fallen, which benefits graduates. He highlighted other supports, including a commitment to discount graduate debts by 20 per cent if re-elected, a 45 per cent increase in rent assistance, and energy bill rebates. He defended the government's record on cost-of-living assistance.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH) · 1 point of order raised

Creative Australia

Background

Khaled Sabsabi was selected to represent Australia at the Venice Biennale. The questioner claimed his artwork featured Hezbollah leader Nasrallah and other controversial figures.

Question

The senator asked why the government was allowing an artist who featured a terrorist leader in his work to represent Australia, given recent antisemitic incidents.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister stated she was not previously aware of the specific artworks mentioned. She agreed that glorifying Hezbollah leaders was inappropriate and condemned Hezbollah unequivocally. She indicated she would seek further advice on the matter but did not commit to reversing the decision immediately.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Climate Change

Background

The deadline for countries to submit new 2035 emissions targets under the Paris Agreement had passed. The question asked about the importance of international targets and the government's timeline.

Question

The senator asked about the importance of Australia setting international emissions targets and whether the government would set a 2035 target before the election.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Jenny McAllister

The minister explained that setting targets provides consistency and predictability for the economy and aligns with global decarbonization efforts. She stated that the 2035 target must be informed by independent advice from the Climate Change Authority, which was still consulting. She emphasized that the government's approach was evidence-based and endorsed by industry, rather than committing to a specific pre-election announcement.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Trade with the United States of America

Background

President Trump declared a 25 per cent duty on steel and aluminium. The question concerned government attempts to obtain an exemption for Australia.

Question

The senator asked if the government had contacted the Trump administration regarding the steel and aluminium tariffs and what the plan was to protect Western Australian jobs if an exemption was not secured.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister highlighted the strong economic relationship between Australia and the US, noting the Prime Minister had recently spoken with President Trump to make a case for an exemption. She stated the government was working closely with the US administration and would continue to press for Australia's interests. She defended AUKUS as being in Australia's national interest despite the senator's criticism.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH)

Q10 Bridget McKenzie Nationals VIC 2:54 pm

Cost of Living

Background

The question challenged the government on rising mortgage repayments and food costs since taking office.

Question

The senator asked how much average mortgage repayments and food costs had increased since the government took power, citing a cost-of-living crisis.

Includes 2 supplementary questions.

Answer from Penny Wong

The minister did not provide specific figures for mortgage or food cost increases. Instead, she argued that inflation is the key factor influencing mortgage rates, noting that inflation had fallen under her government. She listed government measures such as tax cuts, cheaper medicines, and energy relief, which she claimed the opposition had voted against. She concluded by criticizing the opposition's economic policies and leadership.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the source.

Read on OpenAustralia · Official Hansard (APH) · 3 points of order raised

Other debates this day (19)

Answers to Questions Take Note Debate Customs Amendment (Expedited Seizure and Disposal of Engineered Stone) Bill 2024; First Reading Bill Debate Customs Amendment (Expedited Seizure and Disposal of Engineered Stone) Bill 2024; Second Reading Bill Debate Customs Amendment (Expedited Seizure and Disposal of Engineered Stone) Bill 2024; Third Reading Bill Debate · listed Early Childhood Education and Care (Three Day Guarantee) Bill 2025; First Reading Bill Debate · listed Early Childhood Education and Care (Three Day Guarantee) Bill 2025; Third Reading Bill Debate · listed Electricity Infrastructure Legislation Amendment Bill 2025; First Reading Bill Debate · listed Electricity Infrastructure Legislation Amendment Bill 2025; Second Reading Bill Debate Electricity Infrastructure Legislation Amendment Bill 2025; Third Reading Bill Debate · listed Higher Education Support Amendment (End Dirty University Partnerships) Bill 2025; First Reading Bill Debate · listed Higher Education Support Amendment (End Dirty University Partnerships) Bill 2025; Second Reading Bill Debate Human Rights (Parliamentary Scrutiny) Amendment (Consideration of UNDRIP) Bill 2023; Second Reading Bill Debate Moore, Hon. John Colinton, AO Condolence · listed Parliamentary Committee on Human Rights General Debate Right to Protest Bill 2025; First Reading Bill Debate · listed Tasmania: Bushfires Take Note Debate Veterans' Entitlements, Treatment and Support (Simplification and Harmonisation) Bill 2024; Consideration of House of Representatives Message Bill Debate · listed Veterans' Entitlements, Treatment and Support (Simplification and Harmonisation) Bill 2024; Third Reading Bill Debate · listed Workplace Gender Equality Amendment (Setting Gender Equality Targets) Bill 2024; Second Reading Bill Debate

Divisions on this day (22)

1. Human Rights (Parliamentary Scrutiny) Amendment (Consideration of UNDRIP) Bill 2023; Second Reading Not passed 15–24 2. Rearrangement Passed 32–30 3. Rearrangement Passed 33–30 4. Rearrangement Passed 33–30 5. Rearrangement Passed 33–30 6. Rearrangement Passed 33–30 7. Rearrangement Not passed 31–31 8. Selection of Bills Committee; Report Not passed 30–33 9. Selection of Bills Committee; Report Not passed 28–35 10. Stronger Communities Program; Order for the Production of Documents Passed 34–27 11. Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water; Order for the Production of Documents Passed 34–32 12. Consideration of Legislation Not passed 34–35 13. Consideration of Legislation Passed 35–33 14. Parliamentary Committee on Human Rights Not passed 15–37 15. Withdrawal Not passed 32–35 16. Electricity Infrastructure Legislation Amendment Bill 2025; Second Reading Not passed 30–34 17. Electricity Infrastructure Legislation Amendment Bill 2025; Second Reading Passed 37–30 18. Electricity Infrastructure Legislation Amendment Bill 2025; Third Reading Passed 37–30 19. Early Childhood Education and Care (Three Day Guarantee) Bill 2025; First Reading Passed 32–26 20. Early Childhood Education and Care (Three Day Guarantee) Bill 2025; First Reading Not passed 27–32 21. Early Childhood Education and Care (Three Day Guarantee) Bill 2025; First Reading Passed 32–26 22. Early Childhood Education and Care (Three Day Guarantee) Bill 2025; Third Reading Passed 32–26