Home Affairs Legislation Amendment (2025 Measures No. 1) Bill 2025; Second Reading

Senator Roberts supported the bill as a necessary response to immigration failures by both Labor and Coalition governments. Roberts argued that the legislation addressed the release of dangerous non-citizens and highlighted concerns about mass immigration impacting housing and infrastructure. Senator Roberts criticised multiculturalism and advocated for stricter screening and assimilation policies to protect Australian society.

Senator Shoebridge strongly opposed the bill, characterising it as an attack on multiculturalism and the rights of asylum seekers. Shoebridge cited submissions from human rights organisations warning that the legislation removed natural justice protections and risked deporting vulnerable people to unsafe conditions in Nauru. Senator Shoebridge argued the bill undermined democratic principles and ignored the specific risks faced by women, LGBTIQ individuals, and families.

Senator Brockman indicated the Coalition would support the bill to address the NZYQ cohort and prevent endless legal delays. Brockman echoed concerns about the lack of transparency in the Nauru agreement, noting the potential cost of $2.5 billion and the absence of a minimum number of deportees. Senator Brockman expressed little faith in the government's ability to follow through on safety assurances without further legislative intervention.