Question Time AU

Matter of Public Importance

Economy

Senate · Monday 3 November 2025

Official Hansard for this day (APH) · Read this debate on OpenAustralia

At a glance

The debate centred on the economic impact of rising inflation and housing costs, with opposition members arguing that government policies, particularly regarding energy and housing supply, were exacerbating the crisis. Government senators countered that inflation had significantly decreased under their management and highlighted specific relief measures such as tax cuts and healthcare improvements. Crossbench members criticised the lack of poverty data and attributed economic strain to government waste and net zero policies. The discussion concluded without a vote, as is standard for matters of public importance.

Outcome

The matter was discussed in the Senate; no vote was taken.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the official record before quoting.

How the debate unfolded

Opened the debate

Smith argued that inflation and potential interest rate hikes were severely straining households, particularly in Western Australia where housing prices rose by 1.9 per cent in October, outpacing the national average. Smith cited data showing Perth house prices had increased by 9.5 per cent annually to a median of $884,000, with some regional areas seeing increases over 20 per cent. Smith attributed part of this pressure to the government's expanded five per cent deposit scheme, which he claimed drove demand in a supply-constrained market. Smith also referenced letters from teenagers describing stress related to work and inflation, noting that many young people were working part-time to support their households.

Opposition response

Bragg characterised the economy as sick, citing rising inflation, flat capital expenditure, and increasing unemployment. Bragg argued that the government's five per cent deposit guarantee scheme had caused the largest monthly increase in house prices in living memory by boosting demand without addressing supply. Bragg claimed that 85 per cent of jobs created in the previous year were in the non-market sector and criticised the government for lacking a coherent economic agenda. Bragg asserted that the government was ignoring the reality faced by small businesses and ordinary Australians.