Continued the debate
Chaffey opposed the bills, arguing that the government failed to hold public hearings for the Senate inquiry despite receiving numerous submissions. Chaffey contended that the legislation downgraded the role of the Commonwealth Chief Medical Officer by transferring functions to bureaucrats without clinical backgrounds. Chaffey raised concerns that broad powers to withhold information under the Freedom of Information Act would reduce transparency and accountability. Chaffey also highlighted risks regarding privacy and data sharing, noting the lack of independent oversight for data-sharing declarations. Chaffey concluded that the coalition would vote against the bills until these issues were resolved through proper inquiry.