Question Time AU

General Debate

Questions without Notice

Senate · Thursday 30 October 2025

Official Hansard for this day (APH) · Read this debate on OpenAustralia

At a glance

Senator Marielle Smith moved to suspend Senate standing orders to ask a question regarding upcoming changes to women's health funding under the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme and Medicare. Smith argued that the changes were urgent and that non-executive government members had a democratic right to raise issues affecting their constituents, citing previous Senate inquiries into menopause and women's health. Senator Anne Ruston moved that the question be put, effectively ending the debate on the motion. The motion to suspend the orders was not passed, as indicated by the division result.

Outcome

The motion to suspend standing orders was not passed, with a division result of 23 against and 38 in favour.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the official record before quoting.

How the debate unfolded

Opened the debate

Smith argued that the motion was necessary to allow non-executive government senators to ask urgent questions about significant policy changes affecting women's health. Smith cited two recent Senate inquiries into menopause and women's health, noting that hundreds of women had shared experiences of being dismissed by the current system. Smith contended that changes to the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme and Medicare were occurring on 1 November and required immediate parliamentary attention. Smith asserted that denying this question violated longstanding conventions regarding the rights of non-executive members to represent their constituents.

Opposition response

Ruston moved that the question be put, thereby concluding the debate on Smith's motion to suspend standing orders. Ruston did not provide a substantive policy response in the transcript provided, focusing instead on procedural closure.

Votes during this debate

Division 8: Questions without Notice Not passed 23–38