Question Time AU

General Debate

Aboriginal Deaths in Custody

Senate · Tuesday 2 September 2025

Official Hansard for this day (APH) · Read this debate on OpenAustralia

At a glance

Senator Lidia Thorpe moved a motion to give precedence to a matter concerning First Nations deaths in custody, citing a rise in fatalities and systemic racism. She argued for federal intervention using external affairs powers to set minimum standards and create a national oversight body. Assistant Minister Nita Green opposed granting leave for the motion, stating that senators had not had sufficient time to review its complex content. The government indicated it would consider the motion at a later date when all members could properly examine it. The motion was not passed after the question was put.

Outcome

The motion was not passed, with the division recorded as 13 in favour and 27 against.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the official record before quoting.

How the debate unfolded

Opened the debate

Thorpe argued that First Nations deaths in custody are the result of systemic racism and colonial violence rather than isolated incidents. Thorpe highlighted that the number of deaths had risen from 13 to 22 within a month and criticised Northern Territory laws for contributing to high incarceration rates among Aboriginal children. Thorpe called for the federal government to use its constitutional external affairs powers to establish minimum standards for prisons and policing. Thorpe proposed creating a national oversight body to monitor the implementation of the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody and the Bringing Them Home report. Thorpe also urged the government to prohibit the use of capsicum spray and firearms in Aboriginal communities.

Government response

Green stated that the government recognised the importance of the issues raised by Thorpe but opposed granting leave for the motion at that time. Green explained that senators had not had the opportunity to view the complex nature of the motion, which had only recently been circulated. Green argued that members needed adequate time to consider the content, particularly if amendments were required. Green indicated that there were other opportunities for Thorpe to table the motion later in the week for full consideration. Green moved that the question be put, effectively ending the debate on the motion.

Votes during this debate

Division 6: Aboriginal Deaths in Custody Not passed 13–27