Question Time AU

General Debate

Banking and Financial Services

House of Representatives · Tuesday 4 November 2025

Official Hansard for this day (APH) · Read this debate on OpenAustralia

At a glance

Alison Penfold raised concerns regarding the transition to a cashless society and the introduction of digital ID, arguing these changes disproportionately affect older Australians and those in regional areas. She criticised the draft Competition and Consumer (Industry Codes--Cash Acceptance) Regulations 2025 as insufficient due to exemptions and limited scope. Penfold urged the government to expand cash acceptance mandates to all retailers and halt the closure of bank branches. She also expressed strong opposition to digital ID schemes, citing security risks and privacy concerns raised by constituents.

Summary in reported speech - not a transcript. AI-generated, so check the official record before quoting.

How the debate unfolded

Opened the debate

Penfold argued that the push towards digital payments and digital ID leaves vulnerable populations, particularly older Australians in regional electorates, behind. Penfold highlighted issues with unreliable power and mobile networks in towns like Nabiac, Minimbah, and Harrington, which render cashless payments unusable during outages or peak seasons. Penfold stated that cash remains essential for emergencies such as floods and bushfires, and for women escaping domestic violence who require discreet transactions. Penfold criticised the draft cash acceptance regulations as inadequate because they allow exemptions and exclude essential services like medicine and utilities. Penfold called for a broader mandate covering all retailers without exceptions and urged the government to address the decline in banking infrastructure.